Walsworth Wins Full Defense Verdict in Insurance Bad Faith Jury Trial

Walsworth secured a defense verdict for a large insurance carrier after a five-week jury trial in Palm Springs Superior Court, led by Partners Helen Luetto and Elizabeth Huynh and Senior Paralegal Penny Gutierrez. The case involved a policyholder who sued the insurer for breach of contract, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, elder abuse, and violations of Business and Professions Code section 17200 and sought punitive damages.

The lawsuit stemmed from two alleged water-loss incidents at a Palm Springs, California residence which occurred in 2018. The plaintiff claimed the insurer failed to timely and fully pay claims which caused the plaintiff significant personal and financial harm. The lawsuit lasted for more than five years, and the plaintiff was represented by many attorneys.  A settlement was never a viable option in light of the plaintiff’s demands.

“Seeing the jury return a full defense verdict after a five-week trial was incredibly rewarding,” said Partner and lead trial counsel Helen Luetto. “With a case this complex and so many years of history, our focus was on giving the jury a clear, organized understanding of what really happened. Their verdict shows that approach made all the difference.”

Congratulations to the team on a well-deserved victory!